A look at Third Circuit nominee Rebecca Haywood’s qualifications

Senator Pat Toomey reportedly has questioned Rebecca Haywood’s qualifications to be a Third Circuit judge, but a quick comparison of her background with the court’s recently confirmed judges shows that her qualifications compare favorably.

In the past 10 years, there have been 8 judges confirmed to the Third Circuit: Chagares, Jordan, Hardiman, Greenaway, Vanaskie, Shwartz, Krause, and Restrepo.

Of those 8, there are 5 who had served as Assistant U.S. Attorneys (the times of service are approximate):

  • Chagares — 14 years as AUSA, with 5 years as chief of civil division
  • Jordan — 5 years as AUSA
  • Greenaway — 5 years as AUSA, with 2 as chief of narcotics
  • Shwartz — 14 years as AUSA, with 3 as chief of criminal division and 2 as executive AUSA
  • Krause — 5 years as AUSA

Haywood has been an AUSA for 17 years, with 6 years as appellate chief.

Of the same 8, there were 6 who had clerked for federal judges:

  • Chagares — circuit
  • Jordan — district
  • Greenaway — district
  • Vanaskie — district
  • Shwartz — district
  • Krause — circuit and USSC

Haywood clerked twice for WDPA Judge Bloch.

And, while I haven’t run the numbers on this, I’d bet the farm that Haywood has more experience arguing cases in the Third Circuit than any recent Third Circuit nominee. Earlier I linked here to a few of her more significant Third Circuit oral arguments.

Unqualified? Hard to square that with her record.

One thought on “A look at Third Circuit nominee Rebecca Haywood’s qualifications

  1. Matthew Stiegler Post author

    I somehow failed to mention as one of Rebecca Haywood’s qualifications the fact that she’s a graduate of the University of Michigan law school. This was a grievous oversight — partly because Judges Scirica and Nygaard are also Michigan law graduates, but mostly because my own wife is a Michigan law graduate.

    Hail to the victors valiant …

Comments are closed.